Assessment Workload – It’s Not About the Number

Fiona Carroll
La Trobe University

An analysis of assessment requirements across the Bachelor degrees in Agriculture and Biomedicine at La Trobe University found that first-year full-time students complete an average of 55 assessment tasks per semester, compared with approximately 30 tasks in later years. However, the analysis did not distinguish between tasks completed during scheduled classes as learning activities and those undertaken independently.

Discussions about assessment workload are common in higher education. When presented with assessment numbers, educators often explain why particular tasks are necessary, while university management may question whether students are being assessed too frequently.

Yet the concept of over-assessment remains poorly defined. There is limited discussion in educational research about what constitutes excessive assessment or how it affects learning. The term is frequently used in relation to workload without a clear understanding of the educational consequences.

Assessment practices have gradually shifted away from reliance on major summative examinations towards more frequent assessment throughout a teaching period. Research has identified pedagogical benefits associated with regular low-stakes assessment, particularly in online and blended learning environments (1,2).

Nevertheless, the cumulative effect can be considerable. In a 12-week semester, students undertaking four subjects may encounter weekly low-stakes assessments in each subject, alongside additional summative assessment requirements.

The relationship between the number of assessment tasks and the actual workload experienced by students has not yet been investigated in this context and is likely to vary substantially. Rather than concentrating primarily on assessment numbers, I believe greater attention should be directed towards the quality and educational purpose of assessment.

Assessment has a significant influence on student behaviour (3,4). When students are rewarded for completing regular tasks, assessment can increasingly determine how they allocate their study time. This may result in an assessment-driven curriculum in which students prioritise graded activities over broader engagement with weekly learning materials (5).

Consequently, it is essential that assessment tasks themselves provide meaningful learning opportunities. The quality of task design becomes particularly important when students focus their attention on activities associated with marks.

Many low-stakes assessments are intended to support formative learning, even when a small proportion of the final grade is attached to them. Formative assessment differs from summative assessment because its primary purpose is to improve learning rather than simply measure what students have already learned (6).

Effective formative assessment provides feedback that enables students to recognise their strengths, identify areas for improvement and make progress towards learning objectives. The information generated can also help educators adjust teaching activities and improve curriculum design (6).

When regular low-stakes assessments are incorporated into learning materials, their purpose should therefore be clearly established. Educators need to consider whether these activities genuinely support the intended learning outcomes.

Important questions include whether assessment results inform changes to teaching or learning activities, whether students receive actionable feedback, and whether they have opportunities to apply that feedback to subsequent work.

It is also necessary to consider how students engage with the tasks themselves. If the marks are insignificant or the cumulative workload becomes excessive, students may complete assessments superficially or simply guess answers rather than use the activities to strengthen their understanding.

Ultimately, the central question is whether an assessment task achieves its intended learning purpose at the appropriate level of complexity.

The design of low-stakes formative assessments should also reflect the context in which they are used. For example, a pre-laboratory quiz may be intended to ensure that students are adequately prepared before entering the laboratory.

In this situation, students who initially perform poorly should be encouraged to review feedback and demonstrate a satisfactory level of understanding before undertaking the practical activity.

Similarly, assessments completed during classes with assistance readily available may naturally produce high marks. However, high achievement should not necessarily be expected from every low-stakes assessment.

One advantage of low-stakes tasks is that they allow students to experiment, make mistakes and learn from unsuccessful attempts without substantial consequences for their final grade.

If students consistently achieve high marks on straightforward activities, they may develop unrealistic expectations about their abilities or their likely performance in more demanding summative assessments.

There is no universally appropriate assessment model. Different disciplines, educators and learning contexts require different types of assessment to achieve their educational objectives.

Nevertheless, all assessment tasks should be designed around clearly defined learning outcomes, and their effectiveness should be evaluated in relation to those outcomes.

Returning to the original question, does completing 55 assessments in a semester constitute over-assessment? It is not possible to establish an ideal number of assessment tasks that would apply across all courses or contexts.

By prioritising thoughtful assessment design and evaluating learning outcomes, educators may discover that fewer, better-designed tasks can achieve the same or improved educational benefits.

However, developing, validating and reviewing high-quality assessments requires substantial academic time and collaboration. These activities are not always adequately recognised or supported within existing staff workload allocations.

Rather than focusing solely on reducing the number of assessments, a more productive discussion would examine how institutions can provide educators with the time and resources needed to design and continually improve assessment quality.

References

  1. Holmes N. Assess Eval High Educ 2015;40(1):1–14.
  2. Morris R, Perry T, Wardle L. Rev Educ 2021;9(3):e3292.
  3. Biggs J, Tang C. Teaching for Quality Learning at University. 3rd edition, 2007, McGraw-Hill Education.
  4. Ramsden P, Ramsden P. Learning to Teach in Higher Education. 2003, Taylor & Francis Group.
  5. Hattingh T, Dison L, Woollacott L. Australas J Eng Educ 2019;24(1):14–24.
  6. Bennett RE. Assess Educ Principles Policy Pract 2011;18(1):5–25.

About the author

Dr Fiona Carroll

Dr Fiona Carroll is a Lecturer in the Department of Biochemistry and Chemistry at La Trobe University, Melbourne.
f.carroll@latrobe.edu.au

This article first appeared in the ASBMB Education Feature of Australian Biochemist Vol 54 No 3, December 2023, pages 25–26.

< Back to Education


ASBMB Membership Office
T +61 (03) 9907 8648 
E asbmb@wsm.com.au

© 2026 ASBMB. All rights reserved.