Student Panel: Perspectives on Assessment and Academic Integrity at the 2021 ASBMB Education Symposium
Tracey Kuit and Amber Willems-Jones
Tracey Kuit (University of Wollongong) and Amber Willems-Jones (University of Melbourne) speak with undergraduate Biochemistry students Taku Chitambo, Eleanor Lawton-Wade and Ella Scott about assessment and academic integrity.
The 2021 ASBMB Education Symposium included a student panel exploring the experiences of undergraduate students with online assessment and academic integrity.
The panel featured Taku Chitambo, a third-year Bachelor of Science student at Monash University; Eleanor Lawton-Wade, a second-year Bachelor of Biomedicine student at the University of Melbourne; and Ella Scott, a second-year Bachelor of Science student at the University of Sydney.
The discussion provided an opportunity to hear directly from students about how online assessment differs from traditional examinations, how academic integrity can be maintained and how assessment practices might be improved.
The students' responses have been paraphrased and condensed with permission, as noted in the original article.
Do You Think Online and In-person Assessments Are Equivalent? Can You Describe Any Specific Examples?
Eleanor Lawton-Wade
Eleanor considers online and in-person assessments to be different, although this does not necessarily make one less valid than the other. Instead, they tend to evaluate different aspects of student learning.
Traditional examinations frequently emphasise recalling information, while online assessments can place greater emphasis on analysing data and applying knowledge.
Eleanor particularly values assessments involving clinical applications and data interpretation. However, she cautions against making questions so clinically specialised or complicated that they no longer adequately assess the material taught in the subject.
Taku Chitambo
Taku similarly believes that online and face-to-face assessments serve different purposes.
In-person examinations often depend on remembering lecture material and specific terminology. Online assessments, by contrast, can provide opportunities to demonstrate conceptual understanding and apply knowledge to unfamiliar situations.
Taku favours case-study questions because they require students to apply biochemistry concepts to realistic problems. Such questions can reveal gaps in understanding that may not be apparent in tests based primarily on recall.
He is less enthusiastic about simple recall-based quizzes, which may reward students for recognising terminology without demonstrating an understanding of the principles behind it.
How Do You Uphold Academic Integrity as a Student, Both Individually and in a Group?
Taku Chitambo
Taku explains that effective group work begins with a fair distribution of responsibilities.
His groups use collaborative platforms such as Google Docs, where version histories make it possible to identify individual contributions.
Regular group meetings are also important because they allow members to discuss their progress, demonstrate their understanding and confirm that everyone is contributing appropriately.
Unexpected differences between a student's usual communication style and their submitted work can sometimes raise concerns about academic integrity.
Ella Scott
Ella approaches academic integrity in much the same way whether group work takes place online or in person.
She notes that online collaboration can provide greater transparency because contributions and participation can be documented through Google Docs version histories and Zoom attendance records.
Ella also emphasises the importance of completing peer assessments honestly. Evaluating each group member's contribution helps encourage equitable participation and ensures that marks more accurately reflect individual effort.
When concerns arise, she recommends communicating with the subject coordinator as early as possible to prevent difficulties from escalating.
Is Academic Misconduct Openly Discussed by Students, and Do You Have Any Specific Concerns About Academic Integrity?
Biochemistry students, from left: Taku Chitambo, Eleanor Lawton-Wade and Ella Scott.
Taku Chitambo
Having experienced both traditional university teaching and the transition to online education, Taku has observed changes in how academic misconduct is understood.
In a supervised examination room, prohibited actions are generally easier to recognise. Students usually understand the boundaries because cheating requires an identifiable action that breaches examination rules.
Online assessments can make these boundaries less obvious, creating uncertainty about which activities are permitted and how potential breaches should be addressed.
Taku's main concern is ensuring that students receive clear guidance about what they can and cannot do during online examinations and assignments.
He believes students should understand the practical steps required to remain within academic integrity requirements.
Ella Scott
Ella identifies three important concerns associated with academic integrity in digital assessment.
1. Transparency
Universities need to explain clearly what academic integrity means in an online environment, including how collusion is defined when students communicate with one another.
2. Fairness and equity
Ella raises concerns about situations in which some students prepare answers before an examination while others compose their responses during the assessment.
Under strict time limits, these differences may influence how effectively students can demonstrate their knowledge, creating questions about fairness.
3. Productive dialogue
Ella believes academic integrity is best supported through constructive communication between students and academics.
Rather than relying on fear or threats of punishment, universities should encourage open discussion that promotes understanding, cooperation and positive relationships.
What Was Your Experience With Proctored Exams This Year? Do You Have Feedback for Those Considering Their Use?
Ella Scott
Ella completed online examinations using ProctorU in both Biochemistry and Pharmacology.
Both examination arrangements involved recording and restricted internet access. However, Biochemistry permitted students to access locally stored files, while Pharmacology did not.
Ella found proctored examinations somewhat more stressful than examinations without online supervision.
She identifies two major sources of additional stress.
Technical difficulties
Students are responsible for ensuring that their computers and examination software function correctly.
When technical problems occur, students may be uncertain about whom to contact, how to resolve the issue or what evidence they need to provide to demonstrate that a genuine technical failure occurred.
Maintaining examination conditions
Students may also become anxious about unintentionally triggering monitoring software.
Ella describes concerns about ordinary events, such as reading a question aloud or background noise from a rubbish truck, being interpreted as suspicious behaviour.
She considers open-book examinations using ProctorU a potentially effective compromise.
These assessments can maintain identity verification and academic integrity safeguards while allowing students to concentrate more effectively on the examination itself.
If You Could Design an Online Assessment, What Would It Look Like?
Ella Scott
Ella would design online assessments around the opportunities offered by digital delivery rather than attempting to recreate the traditional examination room.
She argues that trying to reproduce every aspect of an in-person examination can introduce unnecessary stress and distractions.
Her preferred approach would include:
Taku Chitambo
Taku would favour an examination based primarily on interconnected case studies and questions requiring students to apply scientific knowledge.
His ideal examination would include:
Taku believes online examinations should generally be open-book, helping provide students with consistent access to learning materials.
He also questions whether adding more examination restrictions necessarily improves academic integrity, as additional controls can introduce technical complications and potential points of failure.
Instead of drawing questions directly from familiar lecture examples, he recommends using fictional diseases or unfamiliar applications that require genuine understanding.
Assigning different case studies to different students could also reduce opportunities for collusion.
Taku would divide assessment across the semester, using a mid-semester examination to evaluate earlier material and a final examination focused on the broader learning outcomes of the subject.
Eleanor Lawton-Wade
Eleanor proposes an examination with two distinct components, each designed to evaluate a different type of knowledge.
Part 1: Closed-book examination
The first component would assess essential knowledge and factual recall.
Eleanor recognises the value of moving towards application-based questions but believes students must still develop a strong foundation of scientific terminology and detailed knowledge.
This component could be proctored, provided students receive clear and transparent information about the monitoring technology.
Part 2: Open-book examination
The second component would assess the authentic application of knowledge through scenario-based questions, data interpretation and more substantial written responses.
Students would be given sufficient time to think critically, develop their arguments and communicate carefully considered answers.
Eleanor believes that unrealistic time pressures can undermine the quality of responses to complex questions, particularly when students are expected to demonstrate reasoning and scientific understanding.
Together, the two examination components would recognise the importance of both foundational knowledge and the ability to apply that knowledge in meaningful contexts.
About the Authors
Tracey Kuit is an Education-Focused Associate Professor in the School of Chemistry and Molecular Bioscience at the University of Wollongong.
tracey_kuit@uow.edu.au
Dr Amber Willems-Jones is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Biochemistry and Pharmacology at the University of Melbourne.
amber.willems@unimelb.edu.au
This article first appeared in the ASBMB Education Feature of Australian Biochemist Vol 52 No 3, December 2021, pages 17–19.
ASBMB Membership Office
T +61 (03) 9907 8648
E asbmb@wsm.com.au
© 2026 ASBMB. All rights reserved.